Closing Costs, Line by Line, and Which Lines You Can Move
On a $420,000 purchase the closing statement came to $14,929. About $4,644 of that was your own money moving into escrow. Of the rest, roughly $2,700 was negotiable and most buyers never ask.
- Published
- Read
- 7 min
- $14,929
- Total closing costs, 3.6% of price
- $4,644
- Prepaids and escrow, not fees
- $2,700
- Realistically negotiable
§On this page(8)
Closing costs get quoted as a percentage. Two to five percent, which tells you what to save and nothing about what to question. Itemised on a $420,000 purchase with a $336,000 loan, the total was $14,929, but $4,644 of that was prepaid interest and escrow deposits, which is your own money moving into an account rather than a cost at all, and roughly $2,700 of the remainder was negotiable.
The Loan Estimate is organised into lettered sections precisely so you can tell which is which. Almost nobody reads it that way. Here is the whole statement, line by line, with the negotiable items marked.
The full statement
$420,000 purchase price, 20% down, $336,000 conventional loan at 6.50%, closing on the 19th of the month.
| Item | Amount | Negotiable? |
|---|---|---|
| Origination fee, 0.5% | $1,680 | Yes. Ask for a reduction or waiver |
| Underwriting fee | $995 | Yes |
| Processing fee | $450 | Yes |
| Credit report | $75 | No. Pass-through cost |
| Flood certification | $25 | No |
| Tax service fee | $85 | Sometimes |
| Section A total | $3,310 |
"Cannot shop" means you cannot choose a different provider. The lender is the provider. It does not mean the amount is fixed. These are the lines a competing Loan Estimate moves.
| Item | Amount | Negotiable? |
|---|---|---|
| Appraisal | $650 | No |
| HOA certification | $200 | No |
| Section B total | $850 |
Genuinely fixed. The appraiser must be independently assigned, which is a post-2008 protection rather than a fee-padding exercise.
| Item | Amount | Typical range |
|---|---|---|
| Title search | $475 | $300–$600 |
| Lender's title insurance | $1,150 | $700–$1,400 |
| Owner's title insurance | $890 | $500–$1,100 |
| Settlement or closing fee | $750 | $400–$1,200 |
| Survey | $450 | $350–$700 |
| Pest inspection | $125 | $85–$200 |
| Section C total | $3,840 |
The lender must give you a written list of providers for these. You are free to use someone else, and the ranges are wide enough that two quotes are worth an hour of your time.
| Item | Amount | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| Recording fees | $185 | Government charge, fixed |
| Transfer taxes, 0.5% | $2,100 | Government charge, fixed by jurisdiction |
| Prepaid interest, 12 days | $852 | Interest you owe anyway |
| Homeowners insurance, 12 months | $1,750 | A bill, not a fee |
| Property tax escrow, 4 months | $1,750 | Your money, held |
| Insurance escrow, 2 months | $292 | Your money, held |
| Combined total | $6,929 |
Transfer taxes vary enormously by state and city. From nothing to well over 2% of the price. Check your own jurisdiction before budgeting, because this single line can swing a closing statement by $8,000.
| Category | Amount | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Lender fees (A) | $3,310 | 22% |
| Third-party services (B and C) | $4,690 | 31% |
| Government (E) | $2,285 | 15% |
| Prepaids and escrow (F and G) | $4,644 | 31% |
| Total closing costs | $14,929 | 3.6% of purchase price |
| Of which is actually a cost | $10,285 | 2.4% of purchase price |
The last line is the honest figure. Escrow deposits sit in an account with your name on it and pay bills you would owe with any lender; prepaid interest is interest for days you own the house.
Free calculator
Check the payment the escrow figures are built around
Where the money actually is
Shop title and settlement
Section C is $3,840 here and the ranges above show why it is the first place to look. Title insurance in particular is priced by state, in some states rates are filed and identical everywhere, in others they vary by hundreds of dollars between providers for the same policy. Call two title companies with the purchase price and loan amount and ask for a quote on the lender's policy, the owner's policy and the settlement fee. It is one phone call and it is frequently worth $400 to $1,200.
Two related points. Ask about a reissue rate, if the seller bought a policy on the same property recently, many underwriters discount a new one substantially, and in a purchase, whether the buyer or the seller pays for the owner's policy is a matter of regional custom, not law; ask your agent which is customary locally before assuming it is your line.
Make lenders compete on paper
A Loan Estimate is a standardised, comparable document, which is what it was designed for. Get two or three, put them side by side, and take the strongest one back to your preferred lender with a specific request: match Section A. Origination, underwriting and processing fees are discretionary revenue, and a lender that wants your file will move on them.
Lender credits, priced
A lender credit is negative points: you accept a higher rate and the lender pays some of your closing costs. It is the mirror image of buying points down, and it is a straightforward break-even calculation rather than a favour.
| Rate | Lender credit | Monthly payment | Extra per month | Break-even |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.50% | $0 | $2,124 | — | — |
| 6.75% | $3,400 | $2,180 | $56 | 61 months |
| 7.00% | $6,700 | $2,235 | $111 | 60 months |
| 6.25% | −$3,300 (you pay points) | $2,069 | −$55 | 60 months |
All four break even around five years, which is not a coincidence. Lenders price the trade so it is roughly neutral over an average holding period. The decision is entirely about your own timeline.
So: if you expect to move or refinance inside five years, take the credit and the higher rate. If this is a long-term house and the rate is already reasonable, pay the costs and keep the lower rate. Neither is clever; the mistake is not knowing the option exists.
Seller concessions
The seller paying your closing costs is often easier to negotiate than a price reduction, because it costs them the same money while keeping the headline sale price intact. The caps depend on your loan type and down payment.
| Loan type | Down payment | Maximum concession |
|---|---|---|
| Conventional | Under 10% | 3% |
| Conventional | 10%–24% | 6% |
| Conventional | 25% or more | 9% |
| Conventional, investment property | Any | 2% |
| FHA | Any | 6% |
| VA | Any | 4% for certain costs, plus all closing costs |
| USDA | Any | 6% |
On this 20%-down conventional purchase the cap is 6% of $420,000, or $25,200. Well above the entire closing statement. The constraint is the negotiation, not the rule.
Checking the Closing Disclosure
You receive the Closing Disclosure at least three business days before closing, in the same format as the Loan Estimate so the two can be compared line by line. Different sections are subject to different tolerances, and this is where errors get caught.
| Section | Tolerance | If it increased |
|---|---|---|
| A. Lender fees | Zero. Cannot increase. | Must be corrected or credited |
| B. Services, lender's provider | Zero | Must be corrected |
| C. Services you shopped, lender's list used | 10% in aggregate | Excess must be credited |
| C. Provider you chose independently | No limit | Yours to have shopped |
| E. Government recording | 10% | Excess credited |
| E. Transfer taxes | Zero | Must be corrected |
| F and G. Prepaids and escrow | No limit | Legitimate. Depends on closing date |
Prepaid interest changing is normal: it is calculated from the actual closing date. A closing that slips from the 19th to the 24th genuinely changes that line, and it is not an error.
The three-day review
- Put the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure side by side and compare Section A first. Any increase is a problem.
- Check the loan amount, rate, term and whether there is a prepayment penalty or balloon payment. Page one, top box.
- Check the cash-to-close figure against what you have arranged to wire.
- Verify your name spelling and the property address, which sound trivial until a recording has to be corrected.
- Confirm the escrow figures against your actual tax bill and insurance quote. An underestimated escrow means a payment increase next year.
- Ask about any line you do not recognise. Three days is enough time to get an answer and not enough to be rushed past one.
Frequently asked questions
- Can closing costs be rolled into the loan?
- On a purchase, generally not. They are paid at closing from your funds, seller concessions or lender credits. On a refinance they can usually be added to the new balance, which means you pay interest on them for the life of the loan.
- Are closing costs tax deductible?
- Mostly not. Discount points and prepaid mortgage interest are generally deductible; origination and processing fees, title insurance and settlement charges are not. Property taxes paid at closing are deductible in the year paid.
- Why is my escrow deposit so large?
- The lender collects enough to have the next tax and insurance bills covered when they fall due, plus a cushion of up to two months. If you close shortly before a tax instalment, the deposit is larger. It is your money and it is reconciled annually.
- Do I need owner's title insurance if the lender already requires a policy?
- The lender's policy protects the lender's interest only. It pays nothing to you if a title defect surfaces. The owner's policy is the one that protects your equity, it is a one-time premium, and for most buyers it is worth having.
More in Buying a Home